Straws
Straws make a simple, and extremely inexpensive
modelling material for prototyping space frames.
Straws have limited strength against lateral forces - but in
hub-and-strut systems, the idea is that such lateral forces
are avoided as much as possible - so this isn't a big
deal.
They are likely to have a limited lifespan - but they are so
cheap that this hardly seems to matter much.
Another good thing about straws is that they are
very light. Weight can easily become very
significant when building large models.
What follows are photographs of a few straw models:
Trusses
Octet truss
|
Dome on concrete (side view)
|
Dome on concrete (top view)
|
Dome on grass (top view)
|
Dome on grass (bottom view)
|
Dome on grass (side view)
|
Hubs
These are cheap plastic hubs.
One of their faces is completely flat.
Straws were also supplied - though using one hub resulted in
the straws fitting the hubs extremely poorly -
resulting in very poor tensile strength properties - which
severely restricted the models which could be
constructed.
The supplier suggests using the hubs two-at-a-time "back to
back". Doing this produces a much better fit with
the supplied straws and results in a stronger joint - but it
doubles the number of hubs needed to build anything with -
and increases the resulting weight.
My guess is that the reason the manufacuter doesn't join the
hubs together themselves is because making them this way
allows them to use a simple "half cast" manufacturing
process - avoiding the need for injection moulding. I
suppose it makes the hubs seem cheaper as well, if they count
half a hub as a hub - though doubling the hub price would
still leave things pretty cheap.
I obtained these hubs from
[here].
The hubs come supplied with lots of flash -
which needs to be removed before use.
Unfortunately, the hubs have no "stop" on the spigots - so
the joins between the straws and the hubs tend to be rather
imprecise.
Since I only had a few hubs I didn't want to double them up.
So I soon switched to using regular "neon" straws from my
local supermarket - which I found fitted the hubs tightly
enough to build reasonable models with - though the hubs
pushed the straws into an unfortunate shape; reducing their
resistance to lateral forces in the process.
I joined the hubs together using brass paper fasteners - the
same ones that I used for constructing
this model -
and [this model].
This was quick, easy and worked well - though I am aware
that brass paper fasteners probably would not work very
well in the intended educational context.
Twin hub close up (from above)
|
Twin hub close up (from below)
|
Hub close up (from below)
|
Hub close up (from above)
|
Hubs doubled up (from above)
|
Hubs doubled up (from below)
|
Standard neon straws
|
Misc
No 5-way or 4-way hubs were available from my supplier.
Fortunately, you can often do this sort of thing:
Icosahedron
|
Octahedron
|
More octet truss fabric
|
Dome on grass (close up)
|
Dome on grass (close up)
|
Links
MUTR's straw system
Astro-Logix
TekKit
Construct-O-Straws (Cochranes)
Construct-O-Straws (Parker)
Construct-O-Straws (Galt)
Connecta Straws (Galt)
Construction Rods
Straws and Connectors (Roylco)
Grafix Building Straws
Molecular Model Parts
Zome
|